UT Law professor weighs in on health care law - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

UT Law professor weighs in on health care law

Posted: Updated:

The debate over the constitutionality of President Obama's health car plan heats up.  Tuesday marked day two of hearings in the nation's capital.  And with only one more day left in court, a local University of Toledo Law professor weighed in on the controversial plan.  Despite heavy criticism of how the government presented the plan, University of Toledo professor, Rebecca Zietlow says she believes the Supreme Court won't repeal it.

It was two years ago, when President Obama signed the Affordable Care Act.  It would affect all Americans and extend insurance coverage to 30 million people who don't have it.  But it's the individual mandate requiring nearly every American to purchase some level of insurance or pat a penalty,that's causing most of the controversy.

"People feel there is this kind of gut feeling that government shouldn't be able to make me by anything," Zietlow says.

She also adds the goal of the mandate is to expand coverage, and keep insurance costs low.

"For those of us who are insured the estimate is that we pay $1000 a year more because of the uninsured out there."

Some say everyone uses health care at some point so the government can require coverage, however, for some on the bench, that argument isn't valid.

Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy says, "the government is saying that the Federal Government has a duty to tell the individual citizen that it must act.  That is different from what we have in previous cases and that changes the relationship of the Federal Government to the individual in a very fundamental way."

But professor Zietlow maintains, the mandate falls within Congress's power to regulate the health insurance market, and, therefore, is constitutional.

She says, "if the court strikes it down, it's a political decision, not on based on principles."

Wednesday is the final day of hearings on this matter.  A final decision is expected in June.

  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Perrysburg talks Louisiana renovation

    Perrysburg talks Louisiana renovation

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 10:15 PM EDT2014-07-30 02:15:43 GMT
    City leaders in Perrysburg are looking at a beautification and renovation project in the downtown area.The $2.3 million proposal includes installing brick at intersections between the railroad tracks and Front street. There are also plans for landscaping down Louisiana and a round-a-bout with the Commodore Perry statue as the centerpiece, complete with fountains."I hope Commodore Perry has a place of honor. If it makes it more beautiful and popular, I'm all for it," Mary Stockwell, a frequent...
    City leaders in Perrysburg are looking at a beautification and renovation project in the downtown area.The $2.3 million proposal includes installing brick at intersections between the railroad tracks and Front street. There are also plans for landscaping down Louisiana and a round-a-bout with the Commodore Perry statue as the centerpiece, complete with fountains."I hope Commodore Perry has a place of honor. If it makes it more beautiful and popular, I'm all for it," Mary Stockwell, a frequent...
  • Mott Library moving across Dorr St.

    Mott Library moving across Dorr St.

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 11:39 PM EDT2014-07-30 03:39:33 GMT
    Built in 1972 and last renovated in '97, Mott Library is due for some updates."We need more room for technology," says Charlie Oswanski, the Facilities Operations Superintendent for the Toledo Lucas County Public Library System. "In that community, there's a wait almost always for a computer."That's just one of the reasons the location is moving, but just a few feet away. System officials plan to build a new 15,000-square foot building right across Dorr Street next to the current MLK Element...
    Built in 1972 and last renovated in '97, Mott Library is due for some updates."We need more room for technology," says Charlie Oswanski, the Facilities Operations Superintendent for the Toledo Lucas County Public Library System. "In that community, there's a wait almost always for a computer."That's just one of the reasons the location is moving, but just a few feet away. System officials plan to build a new 15,000-square foot building right across Dorr Street next to the current MLK Element...
  • Family of murdered Toledo teen prepares for funeral

    Family of murdered Toledo teen prepares for funeral

    He was shot and killed while walking home. As the Toledo teenager's family prepares to bury him, Tyler McIntoush’s says she hopes an arrest is made soon.

    He was shot and killed while walking home. As the Toledo teenager's family prepares to bury him, Tyler McIntoush’s says she hopes an arrest is made soon.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!