New trial for Fulton county cold case - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

New trial for Fulton county cold case

Posted: Updated:
WAUSEON, Ohio -

It is official, another murder trial will be held in Wauseon in a cold case that is almost 30 years old.  Walter Zimbeck learned that Friday.   

When this next trial begins on September 17th, it will be just shy of 27 years since Lori Ann Hill disappeared and was later found dead.  The question now is whether or not another trial will bring a new result? 

Without court officially coming to order, Hill's family members were taken back to the judge's chambers.  The judge met with prosecutors and defense attorneys behind these closed doors.  A decision was made, Zimbeck will face murder charges again.

"I'm very, very excited.  This is the right thing to do for Lori.  Absolutely," said Hill's sister Rachel Barton.

"All I have to say is that the trial has been rest for September 17th and at this point I have no further comment," said Fulton County prosecutor Scott Haselman.

The 14 year old Hill disappeared after a Halloween party in 1985.  Her body was found days later near Swanton.  A grand jury indicted Zimbeck in 2009 in her death, but a judge threw out the case in 2010.  An appeals court reinstated the charges in 2011.

Some of the jurors talked with 13abc.  Some admitted they went back and forth but as a group they could not come to a decision.  Prosecutors are being very tight lipped about this decision, why go forward again, and what their plans are for the next trial. 

13abc asked Haselman, "Why did you decide to go ahead with a second trial?"  Haselman responded, "again September 17th, I have no further comment at this time." 

"Were you surprised today? Not at all, not with all the work Scott Haselmen's done," said Barton. 

13abc tried to contact Zimbeck's attorney but we have not heard back.

  • Top Stories

  • Saturday, May 25 2013 11:54 AM EDT2013-05-25 15:54:24 GMT
    We are following breaking news, Toledo Police say the man found shot inside of a car on North Reynolds near Dorr Street has died. Police say Kenneth Collins, 20, was found unconscious inside of a car
    We are following breaking news, Toledo Police say a man found shot inside of a car on North Reynolds near Dorr Street has died. Police say Kenneth Collins, 20, was found unconscious inside of a car on North Reynolds early Saturday morning.Investigators say a passerby flagged down a trooper who found Collins inside of the car. Collins later died at the hospital.
  • Friday, May 24 2013 11:03 PM EDT2013-05-25 03:03:53 GMT
    A man was filling up his tank when he noticed the pump kept running, even after he finished filling up.  13abc went looking for answers to see what drivers can do if they've been overcharged.
    A man was filling up his tank when he noticed the pump kept running, even after he finished filling up.  13abc went looking for answers to see what drivers can do if they've been overcharged.
  • Saturday, May 25 2013 12:48 PM EDT2013-05-25 16:48:21 GMT
    Thousands of guests had a chance to ride attractions all night long at Disney parks. Three Disney world parks stayed open for 24 hours yesterday -- to kick off the memorial day weekend. Guests pulled
    Thousands of guests had a chance to ride attractions all night long at Disney parks. Three Disney world parks stayed open for 24 hours yesterday to kick off the memorial day weekend. Guests pulled all nighties at the Magic Kingdom in Orlando, Florida, Disneyland and the Disney Adventure Park in Anaheim California.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!