Viewers believe CT shooting media coverage goes too far - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Viewers believe CT shooting media coverage goes too far

Posted: Updated:

National and local media have extensively covered the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, CT over the last four days.  But some news consumers believe the media have been irresponsible with some of the coverage.

13abc reporter Bill Hormann wanted to hear from viewers and received many Facebook messages.  He also spoke with a journalism professor from the University of Toledo.

There was a lot of misreporting in the early hours of the shooting tragedy.

Coverage has been wall-to-wall and on social media it's been literally second to second.

Much of the coverage has been compelling but some of the information has been wrong.

Dr. Jackie Layng told 13abc competition among media sparks inaccurate reporting. "Stations and newspapers and online sources rush to get the story so fast that sometimes they're not checking their sources," she said.

Layng has seen reporters sometimes poorly cover this very emotional story.

"We are the watchdogs," she insists.  "It's our job to go out and cover the story, tell people what's going on, but at the same time, we can push the envelope a little into that and start to become almost voyeurs."

For instance,  during a weekend news conference with a coroner, one reporter asked how many times the children were hit by gunfire.
 
Reporting like that sparked outrage from 13abc viewers who wrote on Facebook...

"It is time to let the families mourn in private..."

Another wrote, "All the attention gives a would-be shooter or bomber or killer a reason to think about the fame."

Some viewers have questioned the angles of the story the media cover.  For instance, ABC News ran a story that included this bit of information:

"There are more registered gun dealers and stores than major supermarkets. More gun sellers than McDonald's restaurants."

Sometimes reporters confuse compassion in their coverage with outright editorializing, as CNN reporter Don Lemon did.

"We need to get guns and bullets and automatic weapons off the streets. They should only be available to police officers and to hunt al-qaeda and the taliban and not hunt elementary school children."

Interviewing children also created angry comment by viewers.

One wrote, "Leave out the drama.  Stop talking with the kids and family. They've been through enough."

Another wrote, "I think it's horrid that the media has got cameras in everyone's face."

Doctor Layng admits journalists are walking a fine line between fast, accurate and compassionate information in our 24/7 news cycle.  She says, "It's difficult to try and balance it.  I think most people in the media do that.  Do we always succeed?  No."

The Newtown, Connecticut shooting is an emotional issue.

When kids are involved and there's the fear of copy-cats, everyone is on guard.

And issues of mental health, gun control. and public safety make this a very complicated story to report and to watch.

But media have a sometimes disturbing responsibility to get information.

It is up to readers and viewers to let us know when they think journalists go too far.

  • LocalMore>>

  • Toledo man pleads not guilty to raping girl, molesting her friends

    Toledo man pleads not guilty to raping girl, molesting her friends

    Monday, September 15 2014 11:03 PM EDT2014-09-16 03:03:39 GMT
    13abc has the angry reaction from the grandfather of one of the girls who says he trusted the suspect Brandon Greer. 
    13abc has the angry reaction from the grandfather of one of the girls who says he trusted the suspect Brandon Greer. 

  • Rossford shows support for local DWTS contestant

    Rossford shows support for local DWTS contestant

    Monday, September 15 2014 10:25 PM EDT2014-09-16 02:25:21 GMT
    You may know him as "Aaron Samuels" from Mean Girls, but before Jonathan Bennett was on the big screen, he was a Rossford Bulldog. Monday, his hometown packed the auditorium to see his debut on ABC's Dancing with the Stars."We decided we were going to celebrate Jonathan and everything he's done," Mayor Neil MacKinnon told 13abc. "He's never forgotten his community, he always comes back and he always gives back."Bennett is a 1999 graduate of Rossford High School.He was very involved in the dra...
    You may know him as "Aaron Samuels" from Mean Girls, but before Jonathan Bennett was on the big screen, he was a Rossford Bulldog. Monday, his hometown packed the auditorium to see his debut on ABC's Dancing with the Stars."We decided we were going to celebrate Jonathan and everything he's done," Mayor Neil MacKinnon told 13abc. "He's never forgotten his community, he always comes back and he always gives back."Bennett is a 1999 graduate of Rossford High School.He was very involved in the dra...
  • Young couple and 6-month-old son pistol whipped

    Young couple and 6-month-old son pistol whipped

    Monday, September 15 2014 7:48 PM EDT2014-09-15 23:48:50 GMT
    A young couple and their six month old baby were pistol whipped while walking to the store. The baby was rushed to the hospital. It happened a little after midnight at the corner of Walbridge and Langdon. "The whole thing is that they hit my grandson like why would you hit a baby. He didn't do anything," said the grandmother. She's afraid to show her face, but you can hear the anger in this grandmothers voice. She says someone robbed her 16 year old daughter, her daughters 19 year old boyfrie...
    A young couple and their six month old baby were pistol whipped while walking to the store. The baby was rushed to the hospital. It happened a little after midnight at the corner of Walbridge and Langdon. "The whole thing is that they hit my grandson like why would you hit a baby. He didn't do anything," said the grandmother. She's afraid to show her face, but you can hear the anger in this grandmothers voice. She says someone robbed her 16 year old daughter, her daughters 19 year old boyfrie...
  • RegionalMore>>

  • MI simulates oil spill

    MI simulates oil spill

    Monday, September 15 2014 3:38 PM EDT2014-09-15 19:38:10 GMT
    Emergency response agencies will participate this week in an exercise simulating a worst-case spill from oil pipelines running beneath the Straits of Mackinac in northern Michigan.
    Emergency response agencies will participate this week in an exercise simulating a worst-case spill from oil pipelines running beneath the Straits of Mackinac in northern Michigan.
  • Gov. Snyder tweaks 'comeback' message

    Gov. Snyder tweaks 'comeback' message

    Monday, September 15 2014 3:04 PM EDT2014-09-15 19:04:46 GMT
    Gov. Rick Snyder has been fond of calling Michigan the "comeback state" for at least 2 ½ years.
    Gov. Rick Snyder has been fond of calling Michigan the "comeback state" for at least 2 ½ years.
  • Arrest in week-old central Ohio school threat

    Arrest in week-old central Ohio school threat

    Police in suburban Columbus have arrested a high school student following a threat of a school shooting scrawled on a school bathroom wall a week ago.
    Police in suburban Columbus have arrested a high school student following a threat of a school shooting scrawled on a school bathroom wall a week ago.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Toledo man pleads not guilty to raping girl, molesting her friends

    Toledo man pleads not guilty to raping girl, molesting her friends

    Monday, September 15 2014 11:03 PM EDT2014-09-16 03:03:39 GMT
    13abc has the angry reaction from the grandfather of one of the girls who says he trusted the suspect Brandon Greer. 
    13abc has the angry reaction from the grandfather of one of the girls who says he trusted the suspect Brandon Greer. 

  • Rossford shows support for local DWTS contestant

    Rossford shows support for local DWTS contestant

    Monday, September 15 2014 10:25 PM EDT2014-09-16 02:25:21 GMT
    You may know him as "Aaron Samuels" from Mean Girls, but before Jonathan Bennett was on the big screen, he was a Rossford Bulldog. Monday, his hometown packed the auditorium to see his debut on ABC's Dancing with the Stars."We decided we were going to celebrate Jonathan and everything he's done," Mayor Neil MacKinnon told 13abc. "He's never forgotten his community, he always comes back and he always gives back."Bennett is a 1999 graduate of Rossford High School.He was very involved in the dra...
    You may know him as "Aaron Samuels" from Mean Girls, but before Jonathan Bennett was on the big screen, he was a Rossford Bulldog. Monday, his hometown packed the auditorium to see his debut on ABC's Dancing with the Stars."We decided we were going to celebrate Jonathan and everything he's done," Mayor Neil MacKinnon told 13abc. "He's never forgotten his community, he always comes back and he always gives back."Bennett is a 1999 graduate of Rossford High School.He was very involved in the dra...
  • Young couple and 6-month-old son pistol whipped

    Young couple and 6-month-old son pistol whipped

    Monday, September 15 2014 7:48 PM EDT2014-09-15 23:48:50 GMT
    A young couple and their six month old baby were pistol whipped while walking to the store. The baby was rushed to the hospital. It happened a little after midnight at the corner of Walbridge and Langdon. "The whole thing is that they hit my grandson like why would you hit a baby. He didn't do anything," said the grandmother. She's afraid to show her face, but you can hear the anger in this grandmothers voice. She says someone robbed her 16 year old daughter, her daughters 19 year old boyfrie...
    A young couple and their six month old baby were pistol whipped while walking to the store. The baby was rushed to the hospital. It happened a little after midnight at the corner of Walbridge and Langdon. "The whole thing is that they hit my grandson like why would you hit a baby. He didn't do anything," said the grandmother. She's afraid to show her face, but you can hear the anger in this grandmothers voice. She says someone robbed her 16 year old daughter, her daughters 19 year old boyfrie...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!