Former dog warden employee acquitted of animal cruelty - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Former dog warden employee acquitted of animal cruelty

Posted: Updated:

A judge throws out the case of a former employee at the dog wardens accused of grabbing a dog by the throat and throwing it in a kennel. The alleged abuse was caught on tape.

The former employee spent 25 days in jail for a crime the judge says he did not commit.

Aaron Nova appeared relieved after a judge acquitted him of animal cruelty charges. Nova always maintained he was innocent. He told a reporter he worked hard to care for the animals.

"I took it very seriously I still do to this day," said former Dog Warden employee Aaron Nova

Nova's trial started today but ended quickly. July of last year Lucas County Dog Warden Julie Lyle testified she was looking for information involving another matter when she came across this video. The dog named Marbles chewed through his leash.

The prosecutor argued when Nova saw Marbles loose he picked up the dog by the neck and abused it.

"Holds him like this walks him down a little hallway of about 6 to 7 cages then at that point Marbles is slammed into a kennel door," said Prosecutor Sharon Gaich.

Nova's lawyer says that's not what happened. He argued there was urine near the cages and his client slipped as he picked the dog up to put him back in his cage.

"The rest of the incident was an emergency situation he was trying as they testified to he was just trying to get that animal back into the cage without causing any injury to himself that dog or injury to other dogs if they interacted that's all he was trying to do and that was clear from the tape. he wasn't trying to hurt that dog," said defense attorney Jerome Phillips.

The Dog Warden and a Humane Society investigator both testified. The Dog Warden says there are no catch poles in that area and the dogs do not wear collars. Nova's attorney asked for the case to be throw out due to lack of evidence. The judge agreed.

"I think what we have here is some evidence that the defendant did not treat the dog properly as a kennel worker and thee human society should treat an animal I am not making that finding because it is not in front of me but I'm saying there is some evidence of that I don not believes there's is evidence of cruelty," said Judge Timothy Kuhlman.

Nova did not say if he plans to fight to get his job back.

  • LocalMore>>

  • 5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    A mother and daughter bike ride for ice cream turned into a close encounter of the "alligator kind." The pair spotted a 5-foot gator in a creek along Roachton Road. But that's not the really weird part of the story.
  • 3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    Thursday, July 24 2014 11:08 PM EDT2014-07-25 03:08:15 GMT
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
  • Muddy the Mudhen up for Best Minor League Mascot

    Muddy the Mudhen up for Best Minor League Mascot

    Thursday, July 24 2014 10:51 PM EDT2014-07-25 02:51:36 GMT
    It's your chance to show your Toledo Mud Hens pride! You can help make Muddy the Mudhen the top mascot in the minor league. He's facing off against 13 other mascots. You can pick your favorite in the league round until August 4, then in the championship round until August 11. Click here to vote, and you can keep voting as many times as you like.
    It's your chance to show your Toledo Mud Hens pride! You can help make Muddy the Mudhen the top mascot in the minor league. He's facing off against 13 other mascots. You can pick your favorite in the league round until August 4, then in the championship round until August 11. Click here to vote, and you can keep voting as many times as you like.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • 3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    Thursday, July 24 2014 11:08 PM EDT2014-07-25 03:08:15 GMT
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
  • 5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    A mother and daughter bike ride for ice cream turned into a close encounter of the "alligator kind." The pair spotted a 5-foot gator in a creek along Roachton Road. But that's not the really weird part of the story.
  • Family, friends remember Cory Barron

    Family, friends remember Cory Barron

    Hundreds of candles lit the Fremont Ross football field Thursday night, but friends and family say it was Cory's life and his love that beamed the brightest.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!