Unsolved murder case in Sandusky Co. reopened after 25 years - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Unsolved murder case in Sandusky Co. reopened after 25 years

Posted: Updated:

The Sandusky County Sheriff has reopened a 25-year-old cold case.

The murder of a Bellevue wife and mother with a hatchet is getting a fresh look with the help of a new cable TV show.

Sandusky County Sheriff Kyle Overmyer says TNT chose his department to be a part of a new reality show that helps law enforcement in small towns. The point is the agencies can't afford to spend time and manpower investigating cold cases. Overmyer says this summer they've interviewed more than 60 people in a gruesome cold case.

Isabel Cordle fell asleep on the couch inside her Bellevue home after getting home late from Bingo on January 24, 1988. The 49-year-old never woke up.

Someone hit her in the back of the head at least three times with a hatchet.

Police found the murder weapon right outside. They say it looks almost staged leaning up against a tree.

"That's the Hatchet House," says Laura Butz who lives a stone's throw away from where the grisly killing occurred.

Butz was 33 years old at the time.

"Well it's just kind of creepy, it always has been creepy just knowing they never caught who did it," says Butz.

Now a quarter century later, Isabel's cold case is reopened with the help of the team on a new TNT reality show called Cold Justice.

"I think we have gone so much further since 25 years ago that we're going to get there and we're almost there right now," says Sandusky County Sheriff Kyle Overmyer.

13 ABC's Christine Long asks, "Are you close to an arrest?"

Overmyer says, "We're getting close. It's like we're hanging on the seat of our pants."

Detectives say Isabel's family was home when she was murdered. Inside the home were her husband Richard and their children who were ages 10, 12, and 14.

Richard Cordle told police they were all asleep and he found his wife dead when he walked downstairs in the morning.

"Richard Cordle the husband is an obvious suspect," says Detective Captain Sean O'Connell with the Sandusky County Sheriff's Office.

O'Connell says in 1988 Richard worked in Norwalk as a foreman at the Van Dresser Corporation which has since closed.

O'Connell says that facility used hatchets.

O'Connell says eight months after the murder, Richard married another woman who worked at Van Dresser named Sue Thompson.

"Why they didn't dig into Richard's past and why they didn't go out to the Van Dresser Corporation and speak with those who knew Sue Thompson, who knew Richard Cordle, I don't know," says O'Connell.

The couple now lives in Fort Wayne, Indiana, where detectives questioned the two twice this summer.

"If Richard didn't do it, I think Richard certainly knows who did it," says O'Connell.

The show 'Cold Justice' is scheduled to premiere on TNT in September.

In the meantime, the sheriff's department is asking anyone who used to work at Van Dresser in 1988 and knew the Cordles to call their office at 419-332-2613.

  • LocalMore>>

  • 5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    A mother and daughter bike ride for ice cream turned into a close encounter of the "alligator kind." The pair spotted a 5-foot gator in a creek along Roachton Road. But that's not the really weird part of the story.
  • 3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    Thursday, July 24 2014 11:08 PM EDT2014-07-25 03:08:15 GMT
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
  • Muddy the Mudhen up for Best Minor League Mascot

    Muddy the Mudhen up for Best Minor League Mascot

    Thursday, July 24 2014 10:51 PM EDT2014-07-25 02:51:36 GMT
    It's your chance to show your Toledo Mud Hens pride! You can help make Muddy the Mudhen the top mascot in the minor league. He's facing off against 13 other mascots. You can pick your favorite in the league round until August 4, then in the championship round until August 11. Click here to vote, and you can keep voting as many times as you like.
    It's your chance to show your Toledo Mud Hens pride! You can help make Muddy the Mudhen the top mascot in the minor league. He's facing off against 13 other mascots. You can pick your favorite in the league round until August 4, then in the championship round until August 11. Click here to vote, and you can keep voting as many times as you like.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • 3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    3 killed when semi flattens car in Fulton Co.

    Thursday, July 24 2014 11:08 PM EDT2014-07-25 03:08:15 GMT
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
    Three people are dead after a crash between a semi and a car in Fulton County Thursday evening. It happened around 5:30 p.m. at the intersection of County Road l and State Route 109. Troopers say the semi was headed northbound on State Route 109, when the car ran through a stop sign. Witnesses tell 13abc the semi actually drove over the top of the car. The three people inside were all killed. The semi driver was not injured.
  • 5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    5-foot gator found in creek along Roachton Rd.

    A mother and daughter bike ride for ice cream turned into a close encounter of the "alligator kind." The pair spotted a 5-foot gator in a creek along Roachton Road. But that's not the really weird part of the story.
  • Family, friends remember Cory Barron

    Family, friends remember Cory Barron

    Hundreds of candles lit the Fremont Ross football field Thursday night, but friends and family say it was Cory's life and his love that beamed the brightest.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!