City/Newspaper in legal battle over gang map - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

City/Newspaper in legal battle over gang map

Posted: Updated:

Should Toledo residents see a map outlining gang activity in their neighborhoods?   The 3-justice panel of the 6th District Court of Appeals in Toledo ruled the Bell administration must release a gang map prepared by the city's police department.

But Tuesday, the administration advised city council Toledo was appealing the case to the Ohio Supreme Court.

While this may seem like a battle over a map, it is really an issue involving crime prevention, the public's right to know, and in an election year, transparency.

Transparency

Councilman Joe McNamara (D), who's running for mayor, wanted to offer a resolution at Tuesday's council meeting asking the mayor to release the police department's gang map.  The Toledo Blade sued the city to gain release of the police department's gang map.

On July 12, 2013,  the 6th District Court of Appeals ruled the city should release that map but the Bell administration is not giving in.

Deputy Mayor Steve Herwat told city council, Tuesday, the court's decision against the city leaves the administration "no alternative except to file an appeal in the Ohio Supreme Court which we did shortly before 1-o'clock, (Tuesday)."

Wednesday, McNamara said he was disappointed with that decision, telling 13 abc reporter Bill Hormann, "I think it's a symptom of a lack of transparency and a lack of holistic approach to dealing with crime."

Crime Prevention

The administration says releasing that gang map will jeopardize investigations and investigation techniques.

But in it's ruling, the 6th District Court of Appeals disagreed.  The justices stated releasing the city's gang map would not jeopardize any police investigation.

Bsed on it's sources, The Toledo Blade created it's own gang map.

In a July 18th editorial, the paper wrote, the official map would "form the basis of a valuable debate about public safety during this year's city election campaign."

Right to Know

One Toledo resident told 13abc he supports the mayor and his efforts to keep this gang map within the police department.  Tirhohn Sanders said releasing the map only gives gang members a heads up, telling reporter Hormann gangs will think "they know where we are, let's move somewhere else."

But other residents believe the mayor to share what the city knows.

Richard Majewski said, "They know where the gang members are and they know where the problems are with the gangs so they should warn the citizens."

Devonte Stovall told 13abc, "It would help in the fact to know what areas to be more cautious in."

Neither the Bell administration nor the Blade wanted to comment now that this case since it is before the state supreme court.

If the court decides to hear the case,  the city has 40-days to file its complaint.  The Blade would have 40-days to respond and then the city would have another 40-days to respond to that

So, this issue could drag into next year.

  • LocalMore>>

  • 3 dead after motorcycle collides with dirt bike in Maybee, MI

    3 dead after motorcycle collides with dirt bike in Maybee, MI

    Saturday, April 19 2014 2:54 PM EDT2014-04-19 18:54:50 GMT
    Three people are dead after dirt bike hit a motorcycle head-on. The Monroe County Sheriff's office says the crash happened around 11:30 Friday night in Maybee Michigan. A fourth person is in the hospital in serious condition.
    Three people are dead after dirt bike hit a motorcycle head-on. The Monroe County Sheriff's office says the crash happened around 11:30 Friday night in Maybee Michigan. A fourth person is in the hospital in serious condition.
  • Waterloo Elementary in contest for $25,000 playground

    Waterloo Elementary in contest for $25,000 playground

    Saturday, April 19 2014 10:34 AM EDT2014-04-19 14:34:23 GMT
    Students at Waterloo Elementary in Monroe, MI, are in need of a new playground, and they're hoping you can help. They're sharing a video online to generate support. Waterloo is one of 12 finalists in a contest to win a 25-thousand dollar playground. It's called "Fuel The Cause," and it's put on by Bridgestone. Waterloo is one of five elementary schools in Monroe and it has the highest poverty rate of them all, at 80%. You can vote for the playground transformation at http://www.bridgestonetir...
    Students at Waterloo Elementary in Monroe, MI, are in need of a new playground, and they're hoping you can help. They're sharing a video online to generate support. Waterloo is one of 12 finalists in a contest to win a 25-thousand dollar playground. It's called "Fuel The Cause," and it's put on by Bridgestone. Waterloo is one of five elementary schools in Monroe and it has the highest poverty rate of them all, at 80%. You can vote for the playground transformation at http://www.bridgestonetir...
  • No injuries after water rescue at Farnsworth Metropark

    No injuries after water rescue at Farnsworth Metropark

    Friday, April 18 2014 10:43 PM EDT2014-04-19 02:43:46 GMT
    Waterville crews are trying to reach passengers on a boat stuck on the Maumee River. It's happening near Farnsworth Metropark in Waterville. No one is hurt, but a family is stuck on a boat that has been
    Waterville crews safely rescued passengers who were stuck on a boat on the Maumee River Friday afternoon. It's happened near Farnsworth Metropark in Waterville.
  • RegionalMore>>

  • Waterloo Elementary in contest for $25,000 playground

    Waterloo Elementary in contest for $25,000 playground

    Saturday, April 19 2014 10:34 AM EDT2014-04-19 14:34:23 GMT
    Students at Waterloo Elementary in Monroe, MI, are in need of a new playground, and they're hoping you can help. They're sharing a video online to generate support. Waterloo is one of 12 finalists in a contest to win a 25-thousand dollar playground. It's called "Fuel The Cause," and it's put on by Bridgestone. Waterloo is one of five elementary schools in Monroe and it has the highest poverty rate of them all, at 80%. You can vote for the playground transformation at http://www.bridgestonetir...
    Students at Waterloo Elementary in Monroe, MI, are in need of a new playground, and they're hoping you can help. They're sharing a video online to generate support. Waterloo is one of 12 finalists in a contest to win a 25-thousand dollar playground. It's called "Fuel The Cause," and it's put on by Bridgestone. Waterloo is one of five elementary schools in Monroe and it has the highest poverty rate of them all, at 80%. You can vote for the playground transformation at http://www.bridgestonetir...
  • Jury finds Amanda Bacon guilty in death of her son

    Jury finds Amanda Bacon guilty in death of her son

    Friday, April 18 2014 5:02 PM EDT2014-04-18 21:02:16 GMT
    The jury found Amanda Bacon guilty in the murder of her son. She was found guilty of murder and child endangerment charges. She was not found guilty of aggravated murder. Amanda Bacon was charged with
    The jury has found Amanda Bacon guilty in the murder of her son. The jury returned a guilty verdict on murder and child endangerment charges. Bacon was not found guilty of aggravated murder.
  • Marshmallows to fall from sky in Wayne County

    Marshmallows to fall from sky in Wayne County

    The forecast in two Detroit-area communities calls for marshmallows.
    The forecast in two Detroit-area communities calls for marshmallows.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • 3 dead after motorcycle collides with dirt bike in Maybee, MI

    3 dead after motorcycle collides with dirt bike in Maybee, MI

    Saturday, April 19 2014 2:54 PM EDT2014-04-19 18:54:50 GMT
    Three people are dead after dirt bike hit a motorcycle head-on. The Monroe County Sheriff's office says the crash happened around 11:30 Friday night in Maybee Michigan. A fourth person is in the hospital in serious condition.
    Three people are dead after dirt bike hit a motorcycle head-on. The Monroe County Sheriff's office says the crash happened around 11:30 Friday night in Maybee Michigan. A fourth person is in the hospital in serious condition.
  • Missing boater's father: "We just want to get him home"

    Missing boater's father: "We just want to get him home"

    Friday, April 18 2014 10:09 PM EDT2014-04-19 02:09:36 GMT
    We are learning more about the two remaining missing boaters on Lake Erie. Bryan Huff of Rossford is an experienced fisherman. His dad says he lived on the lake. Andrew Rose of Maumee works as a bartender
    The Ottawa County Sheriff concluded his department's search for the two remaining missing boaters on Lake Erie Friday evening.
  • District states case for levy to fund new school

    District states case for levy to fund new school

    Saturday, April 19 2014 2:46 PM EDT2014-04-19 18:46:54 GMT
    North Central Schools Superintendent Ken Boyer says they are are in desperate need of a new high school building.
    North Central Schools Superintendent Ken Boyer says they are are in desperate need of a new high school building.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!