City/Newspaper in legal battle over gang map - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

City/Newspaper in legal battle over gang map

Posted: Updated:

Should Toledo residents see a map outlining gang activity in their neighborhoods?   The 3-justice panel of the 6th District Court of Appeals in Toledo ruled the Bell administration must release a gang map prepared by the city's police department.

But Tuesday, the administration advised city council Toledo was appealing the case to the Ohio Supreme Court.

While this may seem like a battle over a map, it is really an issue involving crime prevention, the public's right to know, and in an election year, transparency.

Transparency

Councilman Joe McNamara (D), who's running for mayor, wanted to offer a resolution at Tuesday's council meeting asking the mayor to release the police department's gang map.  The Toledo Blade sued the city to gain release of the police department's gang map.

On July 12, 2013,  the 6th District Court of Appeals ruled the city should release that map but the Bell administration is not giving in.

Deputy Mayor Steve Herwat told city council, Tuesday, the court's decision against the city leaves the administration "no alternative except to file an appeal in the Ohio Supreme Court which we did shortly before 1-o'clock, (Tuesday)."

Wednesday, McNamara said he was disappointed with that decision, telling 13 abc reporter Bill Hormann, "I think it's a symptom of a lack of transparency and a lack of holistic approach to dealing with crime."

Crime Prevention

The administration says releasing that gang map will jeopardize investigations and investigation techniques.

But in it's ruling, the 6th District Court of Appeals disagreed.  The justices stated releasing the city's gang map would not jeopardize any police investigation.

Bsed on it's sources, The Toledo Blade created it's own gang map.

In a July 18th editorial, the paper wrote, the official map would "form the basis of a valuable debate about public safety during this year's city election campaign."

Right to Know

One Toledo resident told 13abc he supports the mayor and his efforts to keep this gang map within the police department.  Tirhohn Sanders said releasing the map only gives gang members a heads up, telling reporter Hormann gangs will think "they know where we are, let's move somewhere else."

But other residents believe the mayor to share what the city knows.

Richard Majewski said, "They know where the gang members are and they know where the problems are with the gangs so they should warn the citizens."

Devonte Stovall told 13abc, "It would help in the fact to know what areas to be more cautious in."

Neither the Bell administration nor the Blade wanted to comment now that this case since it is before the state supreme court.

If the court decides to hear the case,  the city has 40-days to file its complaint.  The Blade would have 40-days to respond and then the city would have another 40-days to respond to that

So, this issue could drag into next year.

  • LocalMore>>

  • Dozens of animals seized from Lucas County home

    Dozens of animals seized from Lucas County home

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:37 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:37:43 GMT
    New details in a suspected case of animal neglect in lucas county. Dozens of animals were taken from a home in holland today, this after a horse was euthanized on the property yesterday. Health department inspectors condemned the house this afternoon and humane society cruelty investigators hauled away everything from pigs and chickens to dogs and rabbits. But the owner says she is going to fight to get all of them back. Cage after cage was loaded up today at this crissey road home. Gary...
    New details in a suspected case of animal neglect in lucas county. Dozens of animals were taken from a home in holland today, this after a horse was euthanized on the property yesterday. Health department inspectors condemned the house this afternoon and humane society cruelty investigators hauled away everything from pigs and chickens to dogs and rabbits. But the owner says she is going to fight to get all of them back. Cage after cage was loaded up today at this crissey road home. Gary...
  • Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:33 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:33:57 GMT
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...
  • Amazing reunion between local woman and her horse

    Amazing reunion between local woman and her horse

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:31 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:31:56 GMT
    An update to a story we first brought you last week. Charges are expected to be filed Tuesday against the owner of four horses in Sandusky County. Sandusky County investigators are calling it the worst case of horse abuse they've seen. The horses were discovered by a passing motorist at a home in Woodville Township July 19th. The motorist called animal cruelty investigators, who seized the horses that night.One of the horses was in such bad shape it had to be euthanized. A second horse named...
    An update to a story we first brought you last week. Charges are expected to be filed Tuesday against the owner of four horses in Sandusky County. Sandusky County investigators are calling it the worst case of horse abuse they've seen. The horses were discovered by a passing motorist at a home in Woodville Township July 19th. The motorist called animal cruelty investigators, who seized the horses that night.One of the horses was in such bad shape it had to be euthanized. A second horse named...
  • RegionalMore>>

  • Michigan inmate mistakenly released for 5 days

    Michigan inmate mistakenly released for 5 days

    Thursday, July 31 2014 3:03 PM EDT2014-07-31 19:03:49 GMT
    Berrien County officials say an inmate waiting to be sentenced for sexually assaulting a child was mistakenly released due to a paperwork problem.
    Berrien County officials say an inmate waiting to be sentenced for sexually assaulting a child was mistakenly released due to a paperwork problem.
  • Fired OSU band director says he was fixing culture

    Fired OSU band director says he was fixing culture

    The fired Ohio State University marching band director says he was working to change a culture of hazing and inappropriate rituals among members.
    The fired Ohio State University marching band director says he was working to change a culture of hazing and inappropriate rituals among members when he was dismissed.
  • Ohio announces second fine against company that feeds inmates

    Ohio announces second fine against company that feeds inmates

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 10:04 PM EDT2014-07-31 02:04:28 GMT
    COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - The state on Wednesday announced a second fine against the private vendor that took over the job of feeding inmates last year as the company defended its operations before a prisons oversight committee. The $130,200 fine against Philadelphia-based Aramark Correctional Services covered continued staffing shortages, unacceptable food substitutions and shortages and sanitation issues, including maggots observed in food service operations at five prisons this month and last,...
    COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - The state on Wednesday announced a second fine against the private vendor that took over the job of feeding inmates last year as the company defended its operations before a prisons oversight committee. The $130,200 fine against Philadelphia-based Aramark Correctional Services covered continued staffing shortages, unacceptable food substitutions and shortages and sanitation issues, including maggots observed in food service operations at five prisons this month and last,...
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • State revokes license of Toledo’s only abortion clinic

    State revokes license of Toledo’s only abortion clinic

    Thursday, July 31 2014 4:48 PM EDT2014-07-31 20:48:29 GMT
    Capital Care Network on West Sylvania Avenue is scheduled to be shut down as a surgery center in less than two weeks.
    Capital Care Network on West Sylvania Avenue is scheduled to be shut down as a surgery center in less than two weeks.

  • Dozens of animals seized from Lucas County home

    Dozens of animals seized from Lucas County home

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:37 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:37:43 GMT
    New details in a suspected case of animal neglect in lucas county. Dozens of animals were taken from a home in holland today, this after a horse was euthanized on the property yesterday. Health department inspectors condemned the house this afternoon and humane society cruelty investigators hauled away everything from pigs and chickens to dogs and rabbits. But the owner says she is going to fight to get all of them back. Cage after cage was loaded up today at this crissey road home. Gary...
    New details in a suspected case of animal neglect in lucas county. Dozens of animals were taken from a home in holland today, this after a horse was euthanized on the property yesterday. Health department inspectors condemned the house this afternoon and humane society cruelty investigators hauled away everything from pigs and chickens to dogs and rabbits. But the owner says she is going to fight to get all of them back. Cage after cage was loaded up today at this crissey road home. Gary...
  • Police incident shuts down NB I-75 at N. Dixie Highway

    Police incident shuts down NB I-75 at N. Dixie Highway

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:34 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:34:41 GMT
    Part of I-75 is closed right now because of a police situation. Police are involved in a situation on the North Dixie Highway overpass. Officers have shut down the northbound lanes and are having drivers exit at North Dixie Highway and then get back onto I-75, avoiding the overpass. Police aren't saying much about the incident. We have a crew on the way and will bring you more information when we get it.
    Part of I-75 is closed right now because of a police situation. Police are involved in a situation on the North Dixie Highway overpass. Officers have shut down the northbound lanes and are having drivers exit at North Dixie Highway and then get back onto I-75, avoiding the overpass. Police aren't saying much about the incident. We have a crew on the way and will bring you more information when we get it.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!