Federal appeals court upholds Ohio Exotic Animal Law - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Federal appeals court upholds Ohio Exotic Animal Law

Posted: Updated:

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - A federal appeals court upheld Ohio's restrictions on exotic animals on Tuesday, rejecting a challenge by owners who had claimed the law was too stringent and forced them to join organizations they disagree with.

Seven owners had sued the state over the regulations, arguing that the law violates their free speech and free association rights.

The owners "believe that private exotic animal ownership, free from government intrusion, should be lawful," an attorney for them wrote in a court brief in August.

But in its ruling, the three-judge panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati said that the owners' constitutional claims lacked merit.

"The burden of regulation may, unfortunately, fall heavier on some than on others, but that, without more, is not enough to render this act unconstitutional," Judge Julia Smith Gibbons wrote in the panel's opinion.

Ohio has defended the law as addressing animal welfare, public health and public safety concerns associated with private ownership of dangerous wild animals.

State lawmakers worked to strengthen Ohio's regulations after a suicidal owner released dozens of creatures from a farm in Zanesville in 2011. Authorities killed most of the animals, which included black bears, Bengal tigers and African lions, fearing for the public's safety.

The law required owners to get a new state-issued permit by Jan. 1 of this year. They must pass background checks, pay fees, obtain liability insurance or surety bonds and show they can properly contain and care for the animal. Otherwise, residents are banned from having the wild creatures.

The law exempts sanctuaries, research institutions and facilities accredited by some national zoo groups, such as the Association of Zoos and Aquariums and the Zoological Association of America.

The owners contend that joining such groups to get an exemption from the law means they would have to associate and fund organizations with which they disagree.

The court said that the owners' unwillingness to meet permit requirements or seek exemptions under the law does not mean that the measure compels them to join certain groups. "The act imposes a choice on appellants, even though it is not a choice they welcome."

The owners also challenged the state's requirement that animals be implanted with a microchip, calling it government intrusion on their property.

The state likened the requirements to installing license plates on cars, exit signs in buildings or fences in yards. And the federal appeals court agreed.

"There is little difference between a law requiring a microchip in an animal and a law requiring handrails in apartment buildings," the judges said.

The owners' appeal came after a federal judge in Columbus sided with the state in upholding the law in 2012.

(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • LocalMore>>

  • Former student sues band director and school district

    Former student sues band director and school district

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 7:11 PM EDT2014-08-27 23:11:29 GMT
    Brianna Linkfield used to attend Jefferson HighSchool. She says last yearshe witnessed her band mate being duct taped by her band director Brian Sullivan . Instead of being silent, the honor roll student says she blew the whistle and paid the price.She tells 13 ABC, "I saw it and I said to the people around me what gives him the right to abuse somebody in the middle of class....occasionally he would get very violent in class he would start throwing chairs across the room, kicking stands and ...
    Brianna Linkfield used to attend Jefferson HighSchool. She says last yearshe witnessed her band mate being duct taped by her band director Brian Sullivan . Instead of being silent, the honor roll student says she blew the whistle and paid the price.She tells 13 ABC, "I saw it and I said to the people around me what gives him the right to abuse somebody in the middle of class....occasionally he would get very violent in class he would start throwing chairs across the room, kicking stands and ...
  • Long-term NOAA study shows wetland loss

    Long-term NOAA study shows wetland loss

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:09 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:09:30 GMT
    "We lost 90% wetlands in this area, so yes we've recovered some, but we've got a lot of work to do,"
    "We lost 90% wetlands in this area, so yes we've recovered some, but we've got a lot of work to do,"
  • Free lunch for Toledo elementary students

    Free lunch for Toledo elementary students

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 5:44 PM EDT2014-08-27 21:44:33 GMT
    All elementary students at Toledo Public Schools started getting a free breakfast last year and this year they can all take advantage of a free lunch too. The free breakfast and lunch programs are paid for through a federal subsidy. Toledo gets that subsidy because the majority of the children in the district qualify for the free and reduced lunch program.Jennifer Spoores is the Glenwood principal, "It can be the difference between anA and anF grade for a student. A student who eats a healthy...
    All elementary students at Toledo Public Schools started getting a free breakfast last year and this year they can all take advantage of a free lunch too. The free breakfast and lunch programs are paid for through a federal subsidy. Toledo gets that subsidy because the majority of the children in the district qualify for the free and reduced lunch program.Jennifer Spoores is the Glenwood principal, "It can be the difference between anA and anF grade for a student. A student who eats a healthy...
  • RegionalMore>>

  • Long-term NOAA study shows wetland loss

    Long-term NOAA study shows wetland loss

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:09 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:09:30 GMT
    "We lost 90% wetlands in this area, so yes we've recovered some, but we've got a lot of work to do,"
    "We lost 90% wetlands in this area, so yes we've recovered some, but we've got a lot of work to do,"
  • Lake Erie island warned not to use well water

    Lake Erie island warned not to use well water

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 10:38 AM EDT2014-08-27 14:38:35 GMT
    Residents of a small Canadian island are being warned not to drink their well water because of potentially toxic algae in Lake Erie. The blue-green algae blooms causing the warning are the same stuff that contaminated the drinking water of about 400,000 people in the Toledo area earlier this month.
    Residents of a small Canadian island are being warned not to drink their well water because of potentially toxic algae in Lake Erie. The blue-green algae blooms causing the warning are the same stuff that contaminated the drinking water of about 400,000 people in the Toledo area earlier this month.
  • Beating the heat on the cheap

    Beating the heat on the cheap

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 5:41 PM EDT2014-08-26 21:41:55 GMT
    Handel's Ice Cream expects big crowds after the start of school.
    Handel's Ice Cream expects big crowds after the start of school.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • One student taken to hospital after school bus crash

    One student taken to hospital after school bus crash

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 5:17 PM EDT2014-08-27 21:17:48 GMT
    At least one student is recovering after an accident involving a Washington Local Schools bus. A district spokesperson says the 7th and 8th grade students were on the bus when it crashed. That person could not tell 13abc how many students were on the bus when it happened.Authorities say one student was taken to the hospital as a precautionary measure. Officials are still working to figure what caused the accident.
    At least one student is recovering after an accident involving a Washington Local Schools bus. A district spokesperson says the 7th and 8th grade students were on the bus when it crashed. That person could not tell 13abc how many students were on the bus when it happened.Authorities say one student was taken to the hospital as a precautionary measure. Officials are still working to figure what caused the accident.
  • Theft at the German American Festival

    Theft at the German American Festival

    Oregon Police need the public's help to nab thieves who hit the German American Festival.

    Oregon Police need the public's help to nab thieves who hit the German American Festival.

  • Former student sues band director and school district

    Former student sues band director and school district

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 7:11 PM EDT2014-08-27 23:11:29 GMT
    Brianna Linkfield used to attend Jefferson HighSchool. She says last yearshe witnessed her band mate being duct taped by her band director Brian Sullivan . Instead of being silent, the honor roll student says she blew the whistle and paid the price.She tells 13 ABC, "I saw it and I said to the people around me what gives him the right to abuse somebody in the middle of class....occasionally he would get very violent in class he would start throwing chairs across the room, kicking stands and ...
    Brianna Linkfield used to attend Jefferson HighSchool. She says last yearshe witnessed her band mate being duct taped by her band director Brian Sullivan . Instead of being silent, the honor roll student says she blew the whistle and paid the price.She tells 13 ABC, "I saw it and I said to the people around me what gives him the right to abuse somebody in the middle of class....occasionally he would get very violent in class he would start throwing chairs across the room, kicking stands and ...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!