Judge orders stay of execution for 2 dogs in pig-killing case - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Judge orders stay of execution for 2 dogs in pig-killing case

Posted: Updated:

There are new developments in the case of two dogs on death row in Monroe County, convicted of killing two show pigs.

A judge ruled Tuesday that Nala and Bugger can stay alive as an appeal moves forward to save the lives of the dogs.

The judge granted a stay of execution, extending the restraining order stopping the dogs from being euthanized until there is a final decision in the appeal.

Last May, the huskies got out of their home and were found inside a barn just over the state line in Michigan. Two pigs were dead in the barn, and the owner of the pigs says she witnessed the dogs attacking them.

A Bedford Township hearing officer investigated, as required by a Michigan law from 1919 protecting livestock and poultry from attacks, and the dogs were found guilty.

They've now been locked up for ten months. The owners are appealing the dogs' death sentence. After granting the stay, the judge urged the owners of the dogs and the pigs to reach a settlement out of court.

"People are spending a lot of money and a lot of time and it's just a shame that you can't come to some kind of a resolution here that is acceptable to everyone," says Judge Michael LaBeau.

"We would love to try to talk it out instead of the appeal because we could be doing that for six months," says Katalin Juhasz, one of the owners of Nala and Bugger.

Juhasz and her mother own the dogs. They say they're willing to pay around $9,000 to the Sonnenberg family, who owned the pigs.  Juhasz says Stephanie Sonnenberg wanted tens of thousands.

"Last we knew it was $45,000 and that was totally ridiculous," says Juhasz. "We don't have that kind of money. We're not wealthy."

The owner of the pigs has never commented to 13abc, but for the first time her attorney has.

Henry Lievens says the Sonnenbergs spent out-of-pocket almost $10,000 on the pigs they showed in 4-H programs.

Lievens says, "If someone stole your $10,000 car and you lost a $35,000 job, what are you really out?" 

He goes on to say, "The family feels awful about this.  We're receptive to an offer, but we haven't received one yet.  In the past, the dog owners have used a negotiating attempt to embarrass and humiliate the Sonnenberg family."

"We've never said anything publicly to try to humiliate her," says Juhasz.

The judge and the attorney representing Bedford Township have offered to help both sides come together.

  • LocalMore>>

  • Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:12 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:12:52 GMT
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
  • Community donates new US flags after vandalism in Flag City

    Community donates new US flags after vandalism in Flag City

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:09 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:09:38 GMT
    Findlay police haven’t made any arrests, but in the past week none of the flags have been vandalized. 
    Findlay police haven’t made any arrests, but in the past week none of the flags have been vandalized. 

  • TFD Promotes First African American Female Lieutenant

    TFD Promotes First African American Female Lieutenant

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:08 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:08:00 GMT
    Lolita Cooper has been serving on the Toledo Fire Department for 13 years.She's one of 57 women on the department. Tomorrow she will be the first African American female to hold the title as Lieutenant.Cooper tells 13 ABC, "Its an esteemed honor to be the first one...but there's nervousness with it...because of being the first and only you will definitely going to be not scrutinized but looked at...and it's a high responsibility because i want to give the department my best." Cooper is also ...
    Lolita Cooper has been serving on the Toledo Fire Department for 13 years.She's one of 57 women on the department. Tomorrow she will be the first African American female to hold the title as Lieutenant.Cooper tells 13 ABC, "Its an esteemed honor to be the first one...but there's nervousness with it...because of being the first and only you will definitely going to be not scrutinized but looked at...and it's a high responsibility because i want to give the department my best." Cooper is also ...
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Toledo Mud Hens pitcher charged in sexual assault case

    Toledo Mud Hens pitcher charged in sexual assault case

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 2:54 PM EDT2014-07-30 18:54:34 GMT
    Toledo Mud Hens pitcher, Evan Reed, 28, is facing multiple charges linked to a sexual assault case. The Wayne County Prosecutors office says Reed allegedly assaulted a woman from Oakland County back in March.
    Toledo Mud Hens pitcher, Evan Reed, 28, is facing multiple charges linked to a sexual assault case. The Wayne County Prosecutors office says Reed allegedly assaulted a woman from Oakland County back in March.
  • Community donates new US flags after vandalism in Flag City

    Community donates new US flags after vandalism in Flag City

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:09 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:09:38 GMT
    Findlay police haven’t made any arrests, but in the past week none of the flags have been vandalized. 
    Findlay police haven’t made any arrests, but in the past week none of the flags have been vandalized. 

  • TFD Promotes First African American Female Lieutenant

    TFD Promotes First African American Female Lieutenant

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:08 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:08:00 GMT
    Lolita Cooper has been serving on the Toledo Fire Department for 13 years.She's one of 57 women on the department. Tomorrow she will be the first African American female to hold the title as Lieutenant.Cooper tells 13 ABC, "Its an esteemed honor to be the first one...but there's nervousness with it...because of being the first and only you will definitely going to be not scrutinized but looked at...and it's a high responsibility because i want to give the department my best." Cooper is also ...
    Lolita Cooper has been serving on the Toledo Fire Department for 13 years.She's one of 57 women on the department. Tomorrow she will be the first African American female to hold the title as Lieutenant.Cooper tells 13 ABC, "Its an esteemed honor to be the first one...but there's nervousness with it...because of being the first and only you will definitely going to be not scrutinized but looked at...and it's a high responsibility because i want to give the department my best." Cooper is also ...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!