Sykes wants city to consider Sin Tax - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Sykes wants city to consider Sin Tax

Posted: Updated:

Smokers in Toledo are the target of what could be a sin tax imposed by the city.   But can the city pass such a tax?

Toledo needs money to balance it's budget and, it has become popular for governments to raise money by imposing what  sin taxes on items like snack foods, sodas and cigarettes.

City councilman Larry Sykes (D) wants Toledo to consider a sin tax on cigarette products to raise money for the budget but the idea may not work.

City councilman Larry Sykes (D) asked the  finance department to investigate imposing a cigarette sin tax.

He told 13abc reporter Bill Hormann, "You could get 25-cents on pack of cigarettes or cigars or a dime or something like that.  We could increase our revenue."

Sykes says that money could fund pools in the summer, kids recreational activities, even homeless shelters.

Taxpayer, and non-smoker, Catarino Hernandez thinks a sin tax is a good idea.  He says, "As long as the money is going to a good cause, I wouldn't disagree with it at all."

Even a smoker like Jimmy Davis sees a benefit to charging him more per pack.  "I believe the city should put taxes on cigarettes because we need more jobs and more income but that's a lot of people that smoke who can't afford."

There is a problem with the sin tax idea:  the city cannot impose a sin tax.  A sin tax is essentially a sales tax and only the County can increase the sales tax."

And Lucas County  commissioner Pete Gerken (D) says, a sin tax is not the way to pay for government.  He says
"It hurts poor people more than rich people.  It doesn't stimulate the economy, in general, unless it's for a specific purpose."

For instance, Cuyahoga County voters approved a sin tax to pay to build several sports arenas.

But Toledo has no project targetted for any sin tax and voters would have to approve one, anyway.

Voters like Valerie Clare would turn thumbs down to paying more for her pack of cigarettes saying, "I think you're taking it out on people who indulge. It's almost discriminatory."

And the city's finance director says the state should use its surplus to help.   George Sarantou told 13abc, "(The state has) a billion and a half dollars and I think it's time for them to say, OK, here's what we can do to help out cities, in particular, Toledo."

And that may be necessary because with regard to a sin tax, Toledo cannot help itself.

So this sin tax idea won't survive.

The city cannot impose it, voters probably wouldn't approve it, and the county doesn't seem interested at all.

  • LocalMore>>

  • Cedar Point among nominees for best U.S. theme park

    Cedar Point among nominees for best U.S. theme park

    Thursday, July 24 2014 12:43 PM EDT2014-07-24 16:43:06 GMT
    Sandusky's Cedar Point is in the running to be named best theme park in the country. The park is competing with 19 other sites for the top spot as part of a readers' choice contest put on by USA Today and 10Best.The online voting ends at noon August 11.In a 10Best contest this spring, readers named the Toledo Zoo the best zoo in the country.
    Sandusky's Cedar Point is in the running to be named best theme park in the country. The park is competing with 19 other sites for the top spot as part of a readers' choice contest put on by USA Today and 10Best.The online voting ends at noon August 11.In a 10Best contest this spring, readers named the Toledo Zoo the best zoo in the country.
  • Large fire damages three vacant homes

    Large fire damages three vacant homes

    Thursday, July 24 2014 7:42 AM EDT2014-07-24 11:42:00 GMT
    Toledo firefighters are investigating the cause of a large fire Thursday morning that damaged three vacant homes.  The flames broke out around 2:00 a.m. in the 1000 block of Harding Drive near South Hawley.  Witnesses say flames broke out at one home and then quickly spread to houses on both sides.  No injuries were reported.
    Toledo firefighters are investigating the cause of a large fire Thursday morning that damaged three vacant homes.  The flames broke out around 2:00 a.m. in the 1000 block of Harding Drive near South Hawley.  Witnesses say flames broke out at one home and then quickly spread to houses on both sides.  No injuries were reported.
  • Breaking News

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Thursday, July 24 2014 5:14 AM EDT2014-07-24 09:14:48 GMT
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
  • RegionalMore>>

  • Insurers owe more than $1.2M in refunds in Ohio

    Insurers owe more than $1.2M in refunds in Ohio

    Thursday, July 24 2014 12:12 PM EDT2014-07-24 16:12:33 GMT
    Federal officials say around 35,000 Ohioans will benefit from more than $1.2 million in refunds from insurance companies because of a provision in President Barack Obama's health care law. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services released the figures Thursday.
    Federal officials say around 35,000 Ohioans will benefit from more than $1.2 million in refunds from insurance companies because of a provision in President Barack Obama's health care law. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services released the figures Thursday.
  • Biden urges infrastructure, job training in Ohio

    Biden urges infrastructure, job training in Ohio

    Vice President Joe Biden will speak to another major civil rights organization - this time in Cincinnati - and Republican leaders are around to offer counterpoints.
    Vice President Joe Biden says investment in infrastructure and job training is needed to increase economic opportunities in the nation's cities.
  • MI governor Snyder re-election gets tepid response

    MI governor Snyder re-election gets tepid response

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 5:12 PM EDT2014-07-23 21:12:56 GMT
    Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder has accomplished much of what he said he set out to do when he was elected four years ago but instead of cruising to re-election on the fulfillment of his 2010 promises, Snyder's bid for re-election has been met with ambivalence.
    Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder has accomplished much of what he said he set out to do when he was elected four years ago but instead of cruising to re-election on the fulfillment of his 2010 promises, Snyder's bid for re-election has been met with ambivalence.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Official: Air Algerie flight 'probably crashed'

    Official: Air Algerie flight 'probably crashed'

    Thursday, July 24 2014 11:18 AM EDT2014-07-24 15:18:12 GMT
    ALGIERS, Algeria (AP) - An Air Algerie flight carrying 116 people from Burkina Faso to Algeria's capital disappeared from radar early Thursday over northern Mali, officials said. France's foreign minister said no wreckage had been found, but that the plane "probably crashed."
    ALGIERS, Algeria (AP) - An Air Algerie flight carrying 116 people from Burkina Faso to Algeria's capital disappeared from radar early Thursday over northern Mali, officials said. France's foreign minister said no wreckage had been found, but that the plane "probably crashed."
  • Breaking News

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Thursday, July 24 2014 5:14 AM EDT2014-07-24 09:14:48 GMT
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
  • Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 9:56 PM EDT2014-07-24 01:56:46 GMT
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!