Supreme Court upholds convicted killer's death sentence - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Supreme Court upholds convicted killer's death sentence

Posted: Updated:

The Supreme Court of Ohio today affirmed a Toledo man's conviction and death sentence for a double murder in 2007.  A jury found Calvin Neyland Jr. guilty of killing his boss at a Perrysburg trucking company and the company's safety director.

Thursday morning, the Supreme Court ruled that the trial court did make errors, but overruled all 19 legal issues raised in an appeal by Neyland Jr.  The suspect alleged that the errors would have changed the outcome of the trial, given the other evidence that proved his guilt.  The Supreme Court ruled 5-2 to uphold the original judgment of the Wood County Court of Common Pleas.

Neyland Jr. began working as a truck driver at Liberty Transportation Company in July 2006.  One year later, managers cited him for driving violations.  They also say they received complaints about the driver from customers.  The company later fired Neyland Jr., after a he was found at fault in an accident.

Police say Neyland shot his boss, Douglas Smith, and the company's safety director, Thomas Lazar on August 8, 2007.  Both were killed.

Neyland Jr. pleaded not guilty to the murders.  A jury found his guilty and the court sentenced him to death.
  • LocalMore>>

  • Lawmakers talk immigration, yet again

    Lawmakers talk immigration, yet again

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:51 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:51:17 GMT
    Nearly 60,000 South American children are still stuck at our nation’s southern border, and now, they’re stuck in the middle of a political battle. Members of Congress are trying to come up with a plan to deal with the influx of unaccompanied children who have traveled thousands of miles - turning themselves in to U.S. authorities to escape from desperate situations in countries like El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala. But still –there’s no compromise in sight. “For those that are not leg...
    Nearly 60,000 South American children are still stuck at our nation’s southern border, and now, they’re stuck in the middle of a political battle. Members of Congress are trying to come up with a plan to deal with the influx of unaccompanied children who have traveled thousands of miles - turning themselves in to U.S. authorities to escape from desperate situations in countries like El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala. But still –there’s no compromise in sight. “For those that are not leg...
  • Parents of 16-year-old shot and killed overnight speak out

    Parents of 16-year-old shot and killed overnight speak out

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:46 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:46:01 GMT
    Searching for a suspect after police say someone gunned down a 16-year-old boy in cold blood. The teen's parents are pleading for help tracking down whoever killed their son.The shooting happened a little after three this morning near Collingwood and Nottingham. Police are reviewing cell phone records and other evidence in this case. They don't have a motive for the killing. "They found my son my heart my baby boy my pride they found my son dead on the streets of toledo" A father is distraug...
    Searching for a suspect after police say someone gunned down a 16-year-old boy in cold blood. The teen's parents are pleading for help tracking down whoever killed their son.The shooting happened a little after three this morning near Collingwood and Nottingham. Police are reviewing cell phone records and other evidence in this case. They don't have a motive for the killing. "They found my son my heart my baby boy my pride they found my son dead on the streets of toledo" A father is distraug...
  • Apt. fire victims say they haven’t received community donations

    Apt. fire victims say they haven’t received community donations

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:39 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:39:16 GMT
    It has been nearly two months since a fire destroyed Hidden Trails apartment complex in Monroe. 50 families lost their homes and all of their belongings. Now former tenants say they haven't received some of the donations made by the community to help them rebuild their lives. 13abc's McKenzie Kuehnlein has the story. Buffalo Wild Wings on Telegraph in Monroe, Michigan is donating 20% of purchases on Wednesday, July 30 to help the victims. Click here to print the certificate.
    It has been nearly two months since a fire destroyed Hidden Trails apartment complex in Monroe. 50 families lost their homes and all of their belongings. Now former tenants say they haven't received some of the donations made by the community to help them rebuild their lives. 13abc's McKenzie Kuehnlein has the story. Buffalo Wild Wings on Telegraph in Monroe, Michigan is donating 20% of purchases on Wednesday, July 30 to help the victims. Click here to print the certificate.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Parents of 16-year-old shot and killed overnight speak out

    Parents of 16-year-old shot and killed overnight speak out

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:46 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:46:01 GMT
    Searching for a suspect after police say someone gunned down a 16-year-old boy in cold blood. The teen's parents are pleading for help tracking down whoever killed their son.The shooting happened a little after three this morning near Collingwood and Nottingham. Police are reviewing cell phone records and other evidence in this case. They don't have a motive for the killing. "They found my son my heart my baby boy my pride they found my son dead on the streets of toledo" A father is distraug...
    Searching for a suspect after police say someone gunned down a 16-year-old boy in cold blood. The teen's parents are pleading for help tracking down whoever killed their son.The shooting happened a little after three this morning near Collingwood and Nottingham. Police are reviewing cell phone records and other evidence in this case. They don't have a motive for the killing. "They found my son my heart my baby boy my pride they found my son dead on the streets of toledo" A father is distraug...
  • Lawmakers talk immigration, yet again

    Lawmakers talk immigration, yet again

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:51 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:51:17 GMT
    Nearly 60,000 South American children are still stuck at our nation’s southern border, and now, they’re stuck in the middle of a political battle. Members of Congress are trying to come up with a plan to deal with the influx of unaccompanied children who have traveled thousands of miles - turning themselves in to U.S. authorities to escape from desperate situations in countries like El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala. But still –there’s no compromise in sight. “For those that are not leg...
    Nearly 60,000 South American children are still stuck at our nation’s southern border, and now, they’re stuck in the middle of a political battle. Members of Congress are trying to come up with a plan to deal with the influx of unaccompanied children who have traveled thousands of miles - turning themselves in to U.S. authorities to escape from desperate situations in countries like El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala. But still –there’s no compromise in sight. “For those that are not leg...
  • Apt. fire victims say they haven’t received community donations

    Apt. fire victims say they haven’t received community donations

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:39 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:39:16 GMT
    It has been nearly two months since a fire destroyed Hidden Trails apartment complex in Monroe. 50 families lost their homes and all of their belongings. Now former tenants say they haven't received some of the donations made by the community to help them rebuild their lives. 13abc's McKenzie Kuehnlein has the story. Buffalo Wild Wings on Telegraph in Monroe, Michigan is donating 20% of purchases on Wednesday, July 30 to help the victims. Click here to print the certificate.
    It has been nearly two months since a fire destroyed Hidden Trails apartment complex in Monroe. 50 families lost their homes and all of their belongings. Now former tenants say they haven't received some of the donations made by the community to help them rebuild their lives. 13abc's McKenzie Kuehnlein has the story. Buffalo Wild Wings on Telegraph in Monroe, Michigan is donating 20% of purchases on Wednesday, July 30 to help the victims. Click here to print the certificate.

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!