Supreme Court upholds convicted killer's death sentence - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Supreme Court upholds convicted killer's death sentence

Posted: Updated:

The Supreme Court of Ohio today affirmed a Toledo man's conviction and death sentence for a double murder in 2007.  A jury found Calvin Neyland Jr. guilty of killing his boss at a Perrysburg trucking company and the company's safety director.

Thursday morning, the Supreme Court ruled that the trial court did make errors, but overruled all 19 legal issues raised in an appeal by Neyland Jr.  The suspect alleged that the errors would have changed the outcome of the trial, given the other evidence that proved his guilt.  The Supreme Court ruled 5-2 to uphold the original judgment of the Wood County Court of Common Pleas.

Neyland Jr. began working as a truck driver at Liberty Transportation Company in July 2006.  One year later, managers cited him for driving violations.  They also say they received complaints about the driver from customers.  The company later fired Neyland Jr., after a he was found at fault in an accident.

Police say Neyland shot his boss, Douglas Smith, and the company's safety director, Thomas Lazar on August 8, 2007.  Both were killed.

Neyland Jr. pleaded not guilty to the murders.  A jury found his guilty and the court sentenced him to death.
  • LocalMore>>

  • Breaking News

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Thursday, July 24 2014 5:14 AM EDT2014-07-24 09:14:48 GMT
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
  • City hosting East Toledo clean-up on Thursday

    City hosting East Toledo clean-up on Thursday

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 10:36 PM EDT2014-07-24 02:36:47 GMT
    An old, abandoned, overgrown factory field near Milroy Street is changing for the better day by day. Neighbors got city permission to start cleaning up the field after a Toledo worker mowed the lawn last Friday. Since then they've been cutting weeds, hauling trash and peeling metal off an old work trailer. They would like to see it completely cleared out."The neighbors were out, and talked to the city and they said we'll tell you what: we'll come back, we'll clean some more up," says East T...
    An old, abandoned, overgrown factory field near Milroy Street is changing for the better day by day. Neighbors got city permission to start cleaning up the field after a Toledo worker mowed the lawn last Friday. Since then they've been cutting weeds, hauling trash and peeling metal off an old work trailer. They would like to see it completely cleared out."The neighbors were out, and talked to the city and they said we'll tell you what: we'll come back, we'll clean some more up," says East T...
  • Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 9:56 PM EDT2014-07-24 01:56:46 GMT
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Breaking News

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Collingwood deadly shooting

    Thursday, July 24 2014 5:14 AM EDT2014-07-24 09:14:48 GMT
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
    Toledo police confirm a man was shot and killed around 3:00 AM on the 2900 hundred block of Collingwood near Nottingham Terrace, just south of Central. At this point, investigators are releasing very little info, but do confirm that neighbors called police after hearing gunshots. Police blocked off Collingwood in both directions .Detectives say there are no suspects. Stay with 13abc for the latest developments throughout the day.
  • Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Nov. levy for Springfield schools a "back up plan"

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 9:56 PM EDT2014-07-24 01:56:46 GMT
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...
    Springfield Local Schools are moving forward to put a levy on the November ballot, but school leaders say it's only as a back up.Voters will see a 7.9 mill levy on the August 5th ballot. If it's shot down, board members want to put it on the November ballot and in order to do that, they have to file the paperwork before the August results are known. Wednesday, board members unanimously approved putting a levy, with the same millage, on in November.Sherri Koback, the board president says the l...
  • City hosting East Toledo clean-up on Thursday

    City hosting East Toledo clean-up on Thursday

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 10:36 PM EDT2014-07-24 02:36:47 GMT
    An old, abandoned, overgrown factory field near Milroy Street is changing for the better day by day. Neighbors got city permission to start cleaning up the field after a Toledo worker mowed the lawn last Friday. Since then they've been cutting weeds, hauling trash and peeling metal off an old work trailer. They would like to see it completely cleared out."The neighbors were out, and talked to the city and they said we'll tell you what: we'll come back, we'll clean some more up," says East T...
    An old, abandoned, overgrown factory field near Milroy Street is changing for the better day by day. Neighbors got city permission to start cleaning up the field after a Toledo worker mowed the lawn last Friday. Since then they've been cutting weeds, hauling trash and peeling metal off an old work trailer. They would like to see it completely cleared out."The neighbors were out, and talked to the city and they said we'll tell you what: we'll come back, we'll clean some more up," says East T...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!