Court denies child's request over visitation - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Court denies child's request over visitation

Posted: Updated:
TOLEDO, Ohio (AP) - A girl whose divorced parents took on her on trips around the world to hide her from one another didn’t have a right to sit at the table during a visitation hearing, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled.

The case involves a custody dispute between the girl’s Russian mother and her American father.

The state’s high court ruled this past week that a juvenile court in Ottawa County was within its boundaries when it denied the girl, now 18, a seat alongside her attorney during the hearings.

The parents of Amelia Garmyn, identified only as A.G. in court documents, divorced in 2001 when she was 5.

Both her parents took her out of the country at various times to avoid court orders. Her Russian mother took her to Moscow and her American father took her to several states along with Costa Rica.

After the divorce was finalized, her mother took the girl back to Moscow where she said her daughter was abducted from her grandmother’s home and taken from Russia to be reunited with her father.

Patrick Garmyn denied accusations that he instructed three men to take the girl.

An agreement reached in a Henry County court in 2002 gave Lolita Garmyn custody of her daughter as long as she remained in the United States and allowed Patrick Garmyn supervised visitation rights.

Her father in 2009 asked a court to approve unsupervised visitation at his North Carolina home. But the girl asked the court to end visitation and wanted to be at the table during those discussions.

The court denied the girl’s requests and granted unsupervised visitation to the father.

“Members of this court can debate whether the trial court’s ultimate decision to exclude A.G., then 13 years old, was eminently reasonable or a close call,” said Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor. “But we cannot honestly debate whether the juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering A.G. out of the courtroom.”

The girl’s attorney, Howard Whitcomb, said the ruling won’t affect Amelia Garmyn because she is now 18 but could impact others in the future.

“It’s about choice,” Whitcomb told The Blade newspaper in Toledo. “Do you have the right of choice? If a child wants to participate.and chooses to do that, we believe the Constitution protects that choice.


  • LocalMore>>

  • Labor Day drivers prepare for construction

    Labor Day drivers prepare for construction

    Thursday, August 28 2014 10:28 PM EDT2014-08-29 02:28:52 GMT
    Helen, Serenia, and Malik Martin are ready for their holiday road trip to Columbus. The mom of three plans her trips before leaving, to make the ride a little smoother."I have a AAA membership so I get the little trip map so I can know where the construction is," says Helen.Construction season is still in full swing, making it a little harder for holiday travelers. Work crews will not be out this weekend, but permanent work zones will still stay in place."When you have all of these permanent ...
    Helen, Serenia, and Malik Martin are ready for their holiday road trip to Columbus. The mom of three plans her trips before leaving, to make the ride a little smoother."I have a AAA membership so I get the little trip map so I can know where the construction is," says Helen.Construction season is still in full swing, making it a little harder for holiday travelers. Work crews will not be out this weekend, but permanent work zones will still stay in place."When you have all of these permanent ...
  • Former Monroe Co. 4-H leader facing child pornography charges

    Former Monroe Co. 4-H leader facing child pornography charges

    Thursday, August 28 2014 5:28 PM EDT2014-08-28 21:28:16 GMT
    50-year-old Robert Stumpmier was already scheduled to go to trial next month for accusations of sex crimes with a 16-year-old boy.
    50-year-old Robert Stumpmier was already scheduled to go to trial next month for accusations of sex crimes with a 16-year-old boy.

  • Authorities investigation 3 bus accidents

    Authorities investigation 3 bus accidents

    Thursday, August 28 2014 5:15 PM EDT2014-08-28 21:15:39 GMT
    The start of the school year is off to a bumpy start for some kids riding the bus, after 3 bus accidents in less than 24 hours. A bus driver even received a ticket for one accident. Sylvania Township police say a truck driver did not yield at a stop sign for the bus and the two collided. This happened near Cory and Springbrook. None of the junior high students on the bus were hurt. The truck driver was taken to the hospital with neck and back injuries. Yesterday a Washington local school bus ...
    The start of the school year is off to a bumpy start for some kids riding the bus, after 3 bus accidents in less than 24 hours. A bus driver even received a ticket for one accident. Sylvania Township police say a truck driver did not yield at a stop sign for the bus and the two collided. This happened near Cory and Springbrook. None of the junior high students on the bus were hurt. The truck driver was taken to the hospital with neck and back injuries. Yesterday a Washington local school bus ...
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Put-In-Bay bar manager indicted for rape

    Put-In-Bay bar manager indicted for rape

    Thursday, August 28 2014 1:09 PM EDT2014-08-28 17:09:08 GMT
    An Ottawa County grand jury has indicted a Put-In-Bay bar manager on rape charges.Christopher Blessing is accused of raping a co-worker. Blessing faces two rape charges from an incident back in May. The victim told police that after work she was invited out for drinks with Blessing. She told police she didn't remember anything until 2:30am when she says the sexual assault happened. The victim went to a Michigan hospital later that next night and that's when police were notified. Blessing appe...
    An Ottawa County grand jury has indicted a Put-In-Bay bar manager on rape charges.Christopher Blessing is accused of raping a co-worker. Blessing faces two rape charges from an incident back in May. The victim told police that after work she was invited out for drinks with Blessing. She told police she didn't remember anything until 2:30am when she says the sexual assault happened. The victim went to a Michigan hospital later that next night and that's when police were notified. Blessing appe...
  • Labor Day drivers prepare for construction

    Labor Day drivers prepare for construction

    Thursday, August 28 2014 10:28 PM EDT2014-08-29 02:28:52 GMT
    Helen, Serenia, and Malik Martin are ready for their holiday road trip to Columbus. The mom of three plans her trips before leaving, to make the ride a little smoother."I have a AAA membership so I get the little trip map so I can know where the construction is," says Helen.Construction season is still in full swing, making it a little harder for holiday travelers. Work crews will not be out this weekend, but permanent work zones will still stay in place."When you have all of these permanent ...
    Helen, Serenia, and Malik Martin are ready for their holiday road trip to Columbus. The mom of three plans her trips before leaving, to make the ride a little smoother."I have a AAA membership so I get the little trip map so I can know where the construction is," says Helen.Construction season is still in full swing, making it a little harder for holiday travelers. Work crews will not be out this weekend, but permanent work zones will still stay in place."When you have all of these permanent ...
  • Blade Briefing 8/28/14

    Blade Briefing 8/28/14

     

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!