Court denies child's request over visitation - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Court denies child's request over visitation

Posted: Updated:
TOLEDO, Ohio (AP) - A girl whose divorced parents took on her on trips around the world to hide her from one another didn’t have a right to sit at the table during a visitation hearing, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled.

The case involves a custody dispute between the girl’s Russian mother and her American father.

The state’s high court ruled this past week that a juvenile court in Ottawa County was within its boundaries when it denied the girl, now 18, a seat alongside her attorney during the hearings.

The parents of Amelia Garmyn, identified only as A.G. in court documents, divorced in 2001 when she was 5.

Both her parents took her out of the country at various times to avoid court orders. Her Russian mother took her to Moscow and her American father took her to several states along with Costa Rica.

After the divorce was finalized, her mother took the girl back to Moscow where she said her daughter was abducted from her grandmother’s home and taken from Russia to be reunited with her father.

Patrick Garmyn denied accusations that he instructed three men to take the girl.

An agreement reached in a Henry County court in 2002 gave Lolita Garmyn custody of her daughter as long as she remained in the United States and allowed Patrick Garmyn supervised visitation rights.

Her father in 2009 asked a court to approve unsupervised visitation at his North Carolina home. But the girl asked the court to end visitation and wanted to be at the table during those discussions.

The court denied the girl’s requests and granted unsupervised visitation to the father.

“Members of this court can debate whether the trial court’s ultimate decision to exclude A.G., then 13 years old, was eminently reasonable or a close call,” said Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor. “But we cannot honestly debate whether the juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering A.G. out of the courtroom.”

The girl’s attorney, Howard Whitcomb, said the ruling won’t affect Amelia Garmyn because she is now 18 but could impact others in the future.

“It’s about choice,” Whitcomb told The Blade newspaper in Toledo. “Do you have the right of choice? If a child wants to participate.and chooses to do that, we believe the Constitution protects that choice.


  • LocalMore>>

  • Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:29 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:29:30 GMT
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
  • Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:28 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:28:35 GMT
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...
  • Sidewalk may hold up road/waterline work

    Sidewalk may hold up road/waterline work

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:10 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:10:19 GMT
    Toledo needs to fix its aging water pipes under city streets and it has a plan to fix several miles of pipe but there are two problems holding back the work.
    Toledo needs to fix its aging water pipes under city streets and it has a plan to fix several miles of pipe but there are two problems holding back the work.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Arrest made in East Toledo kidnapping of infant

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:29 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:29:30 GMT
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
    Toledo police have arrested a man in connection with an attempted kidnapping at an East Toledo hotel Monday. Investigators charged Jaequan Smith with kidnapping and burglary. He was arrested early Tuesday morning. He’s charged with trying to kidnap a 4 and a half month old baby from his mom’s hotel room. It happened around 6:00am Monday at the Days Inn on Miami Street. The mom told police she was walking her boyfriend out of the hotel and left the infant in the room. 
  • Craigslist scam targets owners of missing pets

    Craigslist scam targets owners of missing pets

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:59 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:59:54 GMT
    Craig's List can be a legitimate way to find lost items or pets, but scammers comb the site, and there's never any shortage of angels they take to get your money. This latest one involves missing pets. Mike and Cheri Novitski's one year old Australian Shepherd "Bear" went missing near Fremonton July 6th. They've been searching frantically for him even since, handing out fliers, checking area animal shelters and facilities. They also posted a missing announcement on Craig's List. That's when ...
    Craig's List can be a legitimate way to find lost items or pets, but scammers comb the site, and there's never any shortage of angels they take to get your money. This latest one involves missing pets. Mike and Cheri Novitski's one year old Australian Shepherd "Bear" went missing near Fremonton July 6th. They've been searching frantically for him even since, handing out fliers, checking area animal shelters and facilities. They also posted a missing announcement on Craig's List. That's when ...
  • Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Woodville woman charged with animal cruelty

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:28 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:28:35 GMT
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...
    New details about a story we broke last week. Charges have been filed against the owner of several horses seized by the Humane Society of Sandusky County. According to investigators Michelle Proch of Woodville Township is facing multiple counts of animal cruelty. The horses were spotted by a passerby July 19th and they were taken from the property that night. Investigators says there were four horses on the property. Two were in critical condition and one of them had to be euthanized. They ...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!