Study shows UN maternal health programs don't work - officials p - 13abc.com Toledo (OH) News, Weather and Sports

Study shows UN maternal health programs don't work - officials puzzled as to why

Posted: Updated:
LONDON (AP) — In the past decade, billions of dollars have been spent trying to save the lives of mothers in developing countries using strategies — usually inexpensive drugs — deemed essential by the U.N. health agency.

Yet two large analyses of maternal health programs— including one conducted by the U.N. itself — report that the efforts appeared almost useless, raising troubling questions about why all that money was spent.

While critics are calling for the pricey global initiatives to be significantly overhauled, the programs are still being implemented despite little proof they work. The practices mainly involve things like ensuring women giving birth get cheap drugs such as magnesium sulphate to treat labor complications or pre-emptive antibiotics for those getting a cesarean section.

Even public health officials acknowledge they were taken aback by the studies.

"Nobody could have been more surprised than I was when we got the results," said Dr. Omrana Pasha of Aga Khan University in Pakistan, who led a study of maternal health interventions in six countries in Latin America, Africa and Asia.

"In clinical medicine, we would not prescribe a drug unless multiple trials show that it works," she added. "The FDA won't allow a drug to be marketed without that evidence. But things are different in public health."

At an international meeting of U.N. partners starting Monday in South Africa, health officials are getting ready to ask donors for even more money to pour into maternal health programs. Since 2009, the U.S. has invested more than $13 billion in maternal and child survival, hoping to save lives by supporting "high-impact" health interventions.

According to the research papers, including one done in 30 countries that tracked more than 300,000 women, scientists found no link between the supposedly life-saving interventions and the death rates of women giving birth. Areas that used the interventions didn't have better survival rates for mothers than areas that didn't.

The two papers published last year are the biggest to assess the effectiveness of maternal health strategies, although smaller studies have previously suggested the methods help. But they gained little traction, perhaps because there doesn't appear to be an easy fix.

Experts, meanwhile, are largely stumped as to why their methods failed to prevent deaths.

"We assume that if women get these things, they will be saved. But it's too simple to say one plus one equals two," said Dr. Marleen Temmerman, director of WHO's maternal health department.

She isn't convinced the interventions don't work. She suspects there were problems implementing the strategies.

"Maybe the health facility has the medicine, but the man who has the key to the cupboard is gone," she suggested.

Temmerman also said it would be dangerous if donors abruptly slashed their support for maternal health initiatives.

"The message is not to stop investing, it's to invest money more wisely," she said.

Some experts said existing plans should be adjusted.

"These essential interventions are important but they are not enough," said Sandrine Simon, a public health adviser at Doctors of the World charity. "This is about more than buying the right medicines."

But others said major changes were required to save more women.

"We need to be more honest and serious about past failures otherwise we will keep making the same mistakes," said Bill Easterly, an economist at New York University. "It's not just the fault of countries receiving aid who aren't implementing the technology properly, it's the fault of Western aid agencies and donors who are not trying hard enough to get it right."

  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • TPD: Serial robber strikes again, suspect at large

    TPD: Serial robber strikes again, suspect at large

    Saturday, August 30 2014 10:44 AM EDT2014-08-30 14:44:05 GMT
    A man wanted by police in a series of robberies may have struck again.Overnight, Toledo police say someone held up the "In and Out" mart on the 1600 block of West Sylvania.Investigators identified the suspect as Jonathan Reed, 39, who is wanted in at least seven other recent robberies.According to a police report, Reed entered the store and brought a small box of candy to the counter.When the clerk rang it up and opened the register, the report states "Reed lunged over the counter and grabbed...
    A man wanted by police in a series of robberies may have struck again.Overnight, Toledo police say someone held up the "In and Out" mart on the 1600 block of West Sylvania.Investigators identified the suspect as Jonathan Reed, 39, who is wanted in at least seven other recent robberies.According to a police report, Reed entered the store and brought a small box of candy to the counter.When the clerk rang it up and opened the register, the report states "Reed lunged over the counter and grabbed...
  • Large fire in downtown building caught on camera

    Large fire in downtown building caught on camera

    Saturday, August 30 2014 8:50 AM EDT2014-08-30 12:50:07 GMT
    New video of a fire in a brick building near the Amtrak station. This happened during the 7 o'clock hour Friday evening. 13abc viewer Richard Trevino captured this video of the flames. Firefighters tell us the fire was in a business at 300 Morris. That address is listed as Mandell-Vasquez, Incorporated. No one was hurt. Investigators are still working to find out what started the fire.
    New video of a fire in a brick building near the Amtrak station. This happened during the 7 o'clock hour Friday evening. 13abc viewer Richard Trevino captured this video of the flames. Firefighters tell us the fire was in a business at 300 Morris. That address is listed as Mandell-Vasquez, Incorporated. No one was hurt. Investigators are still working to find out what started the fire.
  • Train hits empty car, deputies search for driver

    Train hits empty car, deputies search for driver

    Saturday, August 30 2014 8:23 AM EDT2014-08-30 12:23:39 GMT
    New details this morning from a train crash we first told you about Friday night on 13abc Action News at eleven o'clock.A cargo train hit an empty car that was stopped on the tracks, just south of Bradner.This happened on Bradner Road near the Greensburg Pike in Montgomery Township.No one on the train was hurt.The crash prompted a search for the driver or whoever was inside of that car.Overnight, Wood County Deputies said they were using thermal imaging cameras to find any people in the dark ...
    New details this morning from a train crash we first told you about Friday night on 13abc Action News at eleven o'clock.A cargo train hit an empty car that was stopped on the tracks, just south of Bradner.This happened on Bradner Road near the Greensburg Pike in Montgomery Township.No one on the train was hurt.The crash prompted a search for the driver or whoever was inside of that car.Overnight, Wood County Deputies said they were using thermal imaging cameras to find any people in the dark ...

Area Events Calendar

See It, Shoot It, Send It!